Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate and Moza Affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
As an Amazon Associate, Driver Labs earns from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate, Driver Labs earns from qualifying purchases.
On paper, both the Asetek Invicta and Simucube 2 Pro are top-of-the-line direct drive pedals with standard quick releases. They're essentially tied in terms of torque output (Invicta edges out SC2 by 2Nm) and drive type. Both also share a PC compatibility rating. It's a draw.
I've seen users struggle with heel-toe coordination on the Invicta, but to be honest, it's not uncommon for drivers to have trouble with this aspect regardless of pedal quality. The real issue lies elsewhere: reliability. Users are reporting premature failure of components, specifically the hydraulic cylinders, which can leave you stranded near the end of warranty (or even before). The thought of spending an entire year's worth of use only to have it fail is infuriating. Don't get me started on the lack of adjustability - it's a minor complaint, but one that can be a deal-breaker for some.
On the other hand, Simucube 2 Pro users are mostly in agreement: it feels great to drive with. However, there are still some common issues at play here - specifically, problems with the wireless connection being unable to power certain peripherals (like a Formula wheel with a large touch screen and LED display). It's not uncommon for users to report high-pitched whine noises when operating their SC2 Pro under high power demand.
The big problem here is the perceived lack of quality control and customer support. Users are reporting issues that seem to stem from installation problems (e.g., improper cable management, loose bolts), which might not be entirely the user's fault. The fact that some users have reported issues with the power supply failing under high load, only for it to continue working at idle, raises serious concerns about the overall build quality.
So who gets my money? Honestly, I'd say neither. But if I had to choose between these two premium direct drive pedals, I'd go with the Simucube 2 Pro - only because it seems to have a slightly more robust build quality (despite its own set of issues). If you're looking for a good value for money and can live with some minor quirks, SC2 Pro might be your best bet. However, if reliability is your top priority, I'd advise exploring other options.
But let's be real - both of these pedals are expensive and have their own set of problems. If you're not willing to accept the risk of premature failure or mediocre build quality, maybe it's time to explore more budget-friendly alternatives that don't break the bank.