Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate and Moza Affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
As an Amazon Associate, Driver Labs earns from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate, Driver Labs earns from qualifying purchases.
Both Simagic Alpha and Asetek La Prima are direct drive wheel bases, which means they're more accurate and responsive than belt-driven systems. They both have standard quick releases and are compatible with PC. However, the Simagic Alpha has a higher torque rating (15Nm vs 12Nm) on paper.
I've seen users praise the Simagic Alpha for its smooth performance and impressive force feedback. But what about the software? Users are reporting that it's still considered beta, but it gets updated regularly and has a dedicated community. The big problem here is that Simagic is a Chinese company, which might raise some concerns about reliability and support. I've heard horror stories about dealing with warranty issues and getting stuck with a faulty product. I've also seen users complain about the Asetek La Prima's pedals, saying they have a "brick wall feel" that's not suitable for all types of racing. Some users love them, but others can't stand them. The wheel itself is cool, but some users miss having a round one for older cars. Users are reporting issues with the Asetek La Prima's customer support, saying it takes time to resolve problems and sometimes requires multiple attempts. I've seen threads about wheels that overheat, quick releases that break, and firmware updates that don't fix issues. It's like dealing with a ticking time bomb – you never know when it'll blow up in your face. The Simagic Alpha has its own set of issues, but they seem to be fewer and far between. Users are reporting some minor software quirks, but overall, the product seems solid. The support team is quick to respond and fix problems with firmware updates.
For those on a budget-friendly price point, the Asetek La Prima might seem like a good option. However, I'd recommend spending more money on a premium product that's less likely to give you headaches in the long run. The Simagic Alpha is my pick for serious sim racers who want a high-performance wheel base with reliable software and support. For casual sim racers or those just starting out, the Asetek La Prima might be a good entry-point. But if you're willing to invest more money, I'd say skip it and go for something that's less likely to give you grief in the future.