Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate and Moza Affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
As an Amazon Associate, Driver Labs earns from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate, Driver Labs earns from qualifying purchases.
On paper, both wheels have impressive specs. The Simagic Alpha Mini offers 10Nm of torque and a direct drive mechanism, while the Asetek La Prima boasts 12Nm of torque with the same drive type. Both are compatible with PCs and feature standard quick releases.
I've seen users report hardware failures in the Simagic Alpha Mini, but it's essential to note that these issues seem to stem from PC hardware conflicts or user error rather than a design flaw. The company's beta software has also raised some concerns, but updates have been regular and well-received by the community. On the other hand, Asetek La Prima users rave about its feedback, but there are reports of polarizing pedal feel that may not appeal to everyone. One user even sold their La Prima due to issues with non-open wheeler/prototype driving experience.
The big problem here is that both wheels have their share of issues, and it's a matter of what users are willing to tolerate. The Simagic Alpha Mini has more reported failures, but these seem to be largely resolvable by tweaking settings or upgrading hardware. Asetek La Prima users praise its performance but mention the premium price point may not be justified for everyone.
Users are reporting that Asetek's customer support is excellent, which might make up for some of the potential drawbacks. However, I've seen enough reviews to know that even with good support, dealing with product issues can be a nightmare – especially when it comes to returns or warranty claims.
For Simracers on a budget-friendly setup looking for a solid entry-point into direct drive, the Simagic Alpha Mini is still a viable option. It's more affordable and has a lower barrier to entry. However, if you're willing to invest in a premium experience with potentially better performance, Asetek La Prima might be worth considering – especially if customer support matters to you.
Ultimately, my money would go to the Simagic Alpha Mini for those who want a solid DD experience without breaking the bank. For those who can afford it and value top-tier performance above all else, Asetek La Prima is the better choice.