Thrustmaster T300 RS GT vs Thrustmaster TS-XW Servo

The Specs: On Paper

Beneath the surface, A and B are virtually identical. Both direct drive setups offer strong torque values (A: 3.9Nm, B: 6.4Nm), impressive for a PC/Xbox combo. Their compatibility with gaming platforms is also spot on. I'll give it to you straight - there's no significant difference in specs.

The Ugly Truth (Real User Experience)

Users are reporting issues with both, but the A has some redeeming qualities. I've seen threads about reliability complaints surrounding the T300 RS GT, but many claim it's overblown - people with problems tend to post more than those without. Some have had zero issues after years of use (over 1000 hours!). But then there are the overheating concerns... a built-in fan might mitigate this issue, but I've heard users struggle with calibration and deadzones in the middle.

Now B, the TS-XW Servo - it's got its own set of problems. I've seen complaints about buzzing noises during startup and calibration issues that can be crippling (deadzone in the middle, what a nightmare!). Repairs are reportedly slow to come by when things go wrong. Some users have had good experiences with this setup as well, but the issue here is consistency - it's hit-or-miss.

The big problem here is trust. Can you rely on these setups after shelling out top dollar? With both products, I'm left wondering if they're worth the gamble.

The Verdict

For a budget-friendly option that won't break the bank (or your sanity), I'd say A - the T300 RS GT - is the way to go. It's got some issues, but users are more likely to report problems than praise it for being flawless.

If you're looking for something with a bit more power and precision, B might be worth considering, but only if you can stomach the risk of reliability issues. I'd recommend looking elsewhere unless you're dead set on direct drive and don't mind taking your chances.